Sonic Adventure Is Janky Fun! - Retro Review

Sonic Adventure was one of the premier titles for the Sega Dreamcast when it launched in Japan in 1998, and in North America and Europe in 1999. Sonic Adventure successfully brought the Sonic franchise to 3D and remains the system's best-selling game. I can only speculate how cool it would have been to see Sonic Adventure at launch, as I didn’t get a Dreamcast until 2006. Even with the system in hand, it wasn’t until this review, nearly 20 years later, that I finally experienced the game. Sonic Adventure 2 remains my favorite of the two games, but Sonic Adventure provides a great sense of fun while playing it, although it isn’t without its faults.

Score 7.5 / 10 · skip to the summary ↓

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Other store links may also earn me a commission at no extra cost to you.

Story

Sonic Adventure gameplay showing a sandy beach with palm trees, a cyan gem, a fence, and a ship with a character on top.

Doctor Robotnik has released an ancient evil from within the Master Emerald with the hopes of using it to destroy Sonic the Hedgehog and the city of Station Square. Robotnik needs the power of all seven Chaos Emeralds to fully realize his plans, so it is up to Sonic and his friends to find them first! Sonic Adventure has a decent story split between its six playable characters. While this can make it hard to follow at times, the game isn’t long enough to forget its more intricate reveals. The plot is conveyed to players through numerous cutscenes that use both in-game assets and a few prerendered scenes. The voice work in use is average, with some solid deliveries but tons of late '90s cheese. The character models look hilarious as these lines are delivered, and I can’t help but enjoy them.

Gameplay

Sonic runs down a rainy city street toward a blue enemy with a police car and HUD showing time and target bar.

You start the story as Sonic as he fights the freshly released Chaos. This start does a decent job of introducing you to Sonic’s new movement and attacks, and after finishing it off, you are brought to Station Square. Station Square acts as one of the game's three hub worlds that you explore to unlock traditional “action” levels and find other power-ups to use on your journey. I’m not a big fan of the hub world system, but it does help to make Sonic Adventure feel bigger than its 9ish main levels would suggest. A train runs between Station Square and the Mystic Ruins, providing fairly seamless interconnectivity that allows items from one location to be transferred to the other, unlocking new locations. Robotnik’s Egg Carrier is the final hub, and it has secrets to discover along with some cool easter eggs.

Being the first 3D Sonic game, it is pleasing to see how much Sonic Adventure got right with its transition from 2D. Sonic’s action stages provide a nice sense of speed as you proceed through them, and the levels are fun to explore when you take the time to slow down. The set pieces are grandiose and have tons of flair, giving it the feel of much more modern games. While these moments take some control away from the player, the spectacle never made me feel this was a bad thing. Stages will also feature fun additional gameplay experiences with things like snowboarding and bumper car racing. Two rail shooting flight stages also help to set up the next chapter of the story while playing as Sonic or Tails.

My favorite of these alternate game modes, however, was pinball. While the Casinopolis stage is rather underwhelming as a whole, the pinball implementation was fun, and the cameo of Nights was well done. Sonic acts as the ball, making it a fun throwback to Sonic Spinball. It makes me wish that we had another Sonic-based pinball game after the GBA release of Sonic Pinball Party. Chao’s were also introduced with Sonic Adventure, and raising them can be fun. Collecting animals from defeated enemies lets you feed them to help them grow and take on various aspects of the rescued animals. You can transfer Chao’s to the Dreamcast VMU, or for the later GameCube release of the game, the GBA, to further train them.

Sonic Adventure gameplay showing Tails on a grassy cliff above clouds with a timer, ring counter, and lives HUD.

As you proceed through Sonic’s story, you will unlock the other 5 characters to play as. Each offers a unique play style compared to Sonic. Tails can fly and has levels made around racing Sonic for Chaos Emeralds. Knuckles is all about rebuilding the Master Emerald by finding its pieces with his gliding and wall-climbing abilities. Amy gets her signature hammer to solve puzzles with while avoiding enemy robots. Big the Cat makes his first appearance in the Sonic franchise and spends it looking for his frog, Froggy. E-102 Gamma uses his laser to defeat the rest of Robotnik’s robot henchmen. While Sonic’s game time feels the most fleshed out, there are plenty of fun moments to be had in the shorter stories of the other characters. Once you finish them all, you get the final story, which reintroduces Super Sonic!

On top of the levels and mini-games, Sonic Adventure features several boss fights for players to overcome. Depending on the story, you may repeat a boss fight from another story just as the alternate character. I thought this overlap would annoy me, but it turned out to be more entertaining than I was expecting. Bosses aren’t very difficult in this game, and the patterns for most can be easily recognized. This may be an area of disappointment for anyone looking for a harder challenge. Thankfully, they never become outright boring encounters. Robotnik’s Egg Viper, however, stands apart in this regard. While the fight isn’t difficult, the game’s use of knockback and other jank collision moments can make it the most frustrating fight of the entire game. Also, don’t let the fake-out at the end fool you…

Audio

Sonic Adventure has fun audio. The soundtrack is more rock-focused, which I have enjoyed listening to. Several of the tracks have lyrics, but those I didn’t pay as much attention to. As previously mentioned, voice work is rather mixed between solid deliveries and cheesy. Knuckles, “Oh no,” as he takes hits, was a particularly funny occurrence. Overall, I can enjoy it, but it certainly gives off a late 90s charm. Sound effects are crisp and help wrap the entire experience together. The skidding sound while stopping is a particularly nice touch.

Visuals

Sonic Adventure gameplay showing Knuckles running on a grassy path past gold rings with a time and ring counter HUD.

Sonic Adventure is a great-looking Dreamcast title. Sonic Team had a specific look for its Dreamcast games, and having tons of playtime in Phantasy Star Online, I like the sense of familiarity Sonic Adventure brings. Models have a good amount of detail to them, and the lighting is fantastic for the time. Environment textures look crisp and give the game a more realistic feel at various points in the journey. Animations can be a bit mixed, with characters’ legs moving very slowly in comparison to their movement speed. But getting that sense of speed is more important, so it is a minor complaint.

What It Could Have Done Better

Sonic runs along a stone bridge over water in a 3D level with a time and rings HUD.

As clichรฉ as it is to say this about a '90s 3D video game, Sonic Adventure's biggest downfall comes from its awful camera system. By using the L and R triggers on the Dreamcast controller, you can spin the camera around your character. Unfortunately, the camera will often hitch or refuse to turn depending on the terrain. This makes it hard to navigate far too frequently, and it can cause a few deaths. At times, the camera will also mess with your movement direction, causing you to run off cliffs like a fool. The camera shifts during some quick scenes also feels quite jarring at times. Collision detection is another area where Sonic Adventure has a big problem. Numerous times in my playthrough, I have fallen through or been thrown through the terrain I was jumping on, or taken hits that didn’t quite line up right. The worst of these came from when I was fighting the Egg Viper and simply fell through the platform where the fight takes place. Having a mini map for the Hub worlds would also have been a nice touch to help with navigation. Thankfully, they aren’t large, so it isn’t hard to memorize where things are. As a nitpick, the game underuses the VMU display during play, just cycling character portraits.

Replayability

Sonic runs along a grassy path beside a wooden fence and cliff wall with a HUD showing time and ring count.

There is a ton of content to keep you playing Sonic Adventure. You have six characters to play as, and after finishing a level, you unlock an emblem. After finishing levels, you can replay them for different goals to unlock more emblems. Emblems can also be hidden around the hub worlds to collect. In total, there are 130 emblems for you to unlock. On top of the emblems, you can try and set records in some of the mini games. Raising Chao’s and racing them is yet another area you can sink tons of time into!

Other Versions

Sonic Adventure gameplay with a blue character flying past a clock tower building and a white gloved hand in the corner.

Sonic Adventure would get an expanded port, dubbed with a DX, released for the GameCube and PC in 2003. This version of the game features tons of extras and enhanced visuals over the original game. In 2010, Sonic Adventure would be ported to the Xbox 360 and PS3, with its DX content being sold separately as DLC. This version of the game featured higher resolution output compared to the GameCube and Dreamcast releases, but it was still presented in a 4:3 aspect ratio. In 2011, this version of the game was also released on Steam. The Steam release can be a bit buggy, so mods are recommended to iron it out. As of this video, the Xbox 360 version of the game is still for sale and playable on Xbox Series consoles, making it and the Steam version the easiest to acquire for new players on modern hardware.

Verdict

Sonic Adventure gameplay screen showing a purple mech vehicle on a space track with a timer HUD in the corner.

While it isn’t my favorite Sonic game, Sonic Adventure has been fun to play through. Each character is unique and adds to the game as a whole. While I don’t care for the hub world design as much, they can be interesting to explore for upgrades and emblems. Controls are straightforward and easy to master. Unfortunately, some janky camera work and hit detection is present that may affect your enjoyment of the game. If you have never played Sonic Adventure before and are even a mild fan of the franchise, you will likely get a lot out of the journey!

SCORE7.5 / 10
  • What I liked
  • ✓ great sense of fun while playing
  • ✓ got right with its transition to 3D
  • ✓ nice sense of speed in action stages
  • ✓ each character offers a unique play style
  • ✓ ton of content for replayability
  • What I didn't
  • ✕ camera often hitches or refuses to turn
  • ✕ collision detection is a big problem
  • ✕ not a big fan of this hub world system
  • ✕ voice work is average with late 90s cheese
  • ✕ Casinopolis stage is rather underwhelming

๐Ÿ›’ Gear in this post

Sonic Adventure (Dreamcast)

Humble BundleeBay

๐Ÿ‡ฏ๐Ÿ‡ต Import a Japanese copy with JPFans: MercariYahoo Auctions

Dreamcast

eBay

RetroTink 4K

eBay

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Other store links may also earn me a commission at no extra cost to you.